FDA Recall: Stewart’s Shops Ice cream for Potential presence of metal
Source: FDA
File Your Claim Now

FDA Recall: Stewart’s Shops Ice cream for Potential presence of metal

Stewart’s Shops • October 02, 2026

FDA Recall: Stewart’s Shops Ice Cream for Metal Contamination

Stewart’s Shops Corp. has issued a voluntary recall of its Heavenly Medley and Vanilla-Chocolate-Strawberry half-gallon ice cream after a consumer discovered a metal fragment in one carton. The affected products were sold between July 17 and October 2, 2026 at all Stewart’s Shops in New York, Vermont, and New Hampshire. Customers should stop eating the ice cream, verify the UPC codes and “Best By” dates below, and return any recalled cartons to a Stewart’s Shops location for a full refund.

Stewart’s Shops Ice Cream Recall Snapshot

  • Brand: Stewart’s Shops
  • Recalled flavors: Heavenly Medley; Vanilla-Chocolate-Strawberry (½-gallon cartons)
  • Hazard: Possible metal fragments (foreign object contamination)
  • States affected: New York, Vermont, New Hampshire
  • Date range sold: 7/17/2026 – 10/2/2026
  • Reported injuries: None as of the FDA notice (10/2/2026)
  • Consumer action: Do not consume; return for a full refund
  • Contact: Robin Cooper, 518-248-0455, rcooper@stewartsshops.com

Sources

How to Identify Recalled Cartons

Flavor UPC Best By Package Size
Heavenly Medley 0 82086 44371 1 FEB 10 2027 ½ Gallon (1.89 L)
Vanilla-Chocolate-Strawberry 0 82086 44377 3 FEB 11 2027 ½ Gallon (1.89 L)

What Should Consumers Do?

If you purchased either flavor during the affected dates, follow these steps:

  1. Locate the UPC and Best By date on the side panel of the carton.
  2. Do not eat the ice cream, even if it appears normal.
  3. Return the product to any Stewart’s Shops location for a full refund.
  4. Direct any questions to the contact listed above.

Why Metal Fragments in Food Are Dangerous

Even tiny metal pieces can cause choking, dental damage, or internal injuries. The FDA and Stewart’s Shops therefore advise immediately discarding or returning the recalled ice cream.

Image Gallery from the Recall Notice

Stewart’s Shops Heavenly Medley Ice Cream half-gallon carton
Source: FDA
Stewart’s Shops Vanilla-Chocolate-Strawberry Ice Cream half-gallon carton
Source: FDA

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Which Stewart’s Shops ice cream flavors are recalled in 2026?
The recall includes Heavenly Medley and Vanilla-Chocolate-Strawberry half-gallon cartons sold between July 17 and October 2, 2026.
2. How can I confirm my Stewart’s Shops ice cream is included in the metal contamination recall?
Check for UPC 0 82086 44371 1 (Heavenly Medley) or UPC 0 82086 44377 3 (Vanilla-Chocolate-Strawberry) and the Best By dates FEB 10 2027 or FEB 11 2027.
3. Is it safe to eat any portion of the recalled Stewart’s Shops Heavenly Medley ice cream?
No. Because metal fragments may be present anywhere in the carton, the product should not be consumed under any circumstances.
4. What refund will Stewart’s Shops provide for the recalled Vanilla-Chocolate-Strawberry ice cream?
Stewart’s Shops will issue a full purchase-price refund when you return the affected carton to any store location.
5. Have any injuries been reported from the Stewart’s Shops ice cream recall?
As of the FDA announcement on October 2, 2026, no injuries or illnesses have been reported.
6. Can I return the recalled Stewart’s Shops ice cream without a receipt?
Yes. A receipt is not required; simply bring the recalled carton back to any Stewart’s Shops location for a refund.
7. Who can I contact for more information about the ice cream recall?
Call Robin Cooper at 518-248-0455 or email rcooper@stewartsshops.com.

File Your Claim Now