Grandma Belle’s Tomato Basil Soup Recalled for Undeclared Milk Allergen
Immediate Action Recommended: Lil’ Turtles has issued a voluntary nationwide recall of all lots of Grandma Belle’s Tomato Basil Soup because the product contains milk that is not declared on the label. Anyone with a milk allergy or severe sensitivity could experience a life-threatening reaction. Consumers should stop using the soup and contact the company for a free replacement.
Grandma Belle’s Tomato Basil Soup Recall — Quick Facts
- Brand / Manufacturer: Grandma Belle’s (Lil’ Turtles)
- Product Size: 17-oz glass jars
- Hazard: Undeclared milk allergen
- Units on the Market: All production lots sold from September 23, 2022 through December 3, 2025
- Distribution: Independent and specialty grocers in OH, PA, NY, KY, MN, UT, OK, KS, MS, IL, IN, MO, WI, and IA (full list below)
- Reported Reactions: None as of the FDA’s December 9, 2025 notice
- Consumer Contact: Lil’ Turtles, 330-897-6400 (ask for Josh Coblentz)
- Recommended Action: Do not eat the soup; call for a replacement or safely discard it.
Sources
Retailers That Received the Recalled Soup
Grandma Belle’s Tomato Basil Soup was shipped to the following stores:
- Baltic Meats — Baltic, OH
- Trailside Deli — Millersburg, OH
- Randles Cheese — Millersburg, OH
- Wesley Miller — Sugarcreek, OH
- Bambi Farm Market — Orient, OH
- Baker Florist — Dover, OH
- Jungle Jim — Cincinnati, OH
- Becks Market — Greenville, OH
- Indian Trail Country Market — Elizabethville, PA
- Burger Farms — Drums, PA
- Paul’s Country Market — Waynesboro, PA
- The Olde Bat Factory — Hancock, NY
- Shadyview Farm — Rushville, NY
- Beef and Butter Company — Rochester, NY
- Hymers Farm Market — Delhi, NY
- Troyers Country Store — Canastota, NY
- Creekside Pantry — London, KY
- Cherry Grove Market — Browerville, MN
- Applecreek Willard — Willard, UT
- Amish Cheesehouse — Chouteau, OK
- Martins House Country Store — Davis, OK
- Jet Produce — Leavenworth, KS
- 45 Flea Market — Meridian, MS
- Countryside Variety — Buncombe, IL
- Dented Can — Goshen, IN
- Sommher’s Bakery — Gosport, IN
- Sunnyside Market — El Dorado, MO
- Hecks Farm Market — Arena, WI
- Golden Delight Bakery — Kalona, IA
What Consumers Should Do
- People with a milk allergy or sensitivity should not consume Grandma Belle’s Tomato Basil Soup.
- Keep the jar closed and contact Lil’ Turtles at 330-897-6400 for a replacement product.
- You may also return the soup to the store for a refund or dispose of it in a way that prevents accidental consumption.
Product Photos
Frequently Asked Questions
Why was Grandma Belle’s Tomato Basil Soup recalled?
The soup contains milk that is not declared on the ingredient label, posing a serious risk to people with milk allergies.
Which dates or lot codes of Grandma Belle’s Tomato Basil Soup are affected?
Every lot sold between September 23, 2022 and December 3, 2025 is covered by the recall.
Is Grandma Belle’s Tomato Basil Soup safe if I do not have a milk allergy?
While it is not hazardous for individuals without a milk allergy, the FDA still recommends discarding or returning recalled products to prevent cross-contact or accidental consumption by someone who is allergic.
Have any illnesses been linked to Grandma Belle’s Tomato Basil Soup?
No allergic reactions or illnesses had been reported at the time of the FDA notice on December 9, 2025.
Where was Grandma Belle’s Tomato Basil Soup sold?
The soup was distributed to specialty retailers in 14 states. A full store list is provided above.
What is the refund or replacement policy for Grandma Belle’s Tomato Basil Soup?
Call Lil’ Turtles at 330-897-6400 to request a free replacement pack. Stores may also issue a refund at their discretion.
Who can I contact about the Grandma Belle’s Tomato Basil Soup recall?
Direct all questions to Josh Coblentz at Lil’ Turtles by calling 330-897-6400.