Source: FDA

FDA Recall: Blue Oven Bakery, Inc. English muffin for Undeclared milk

Q: Why are Blue Oven Bakery English Muffins being recalled?

The English Muffins contain undeclared milk, which violates allergen-labeling regulations and can cause serious reactions in milk-allergic consumers.

Q: Which stores carried the recalled Blue Oven Bakery English Muffins?

The muffins were sold at Harvest Market, Country Fresh Market, Kremers Market, Back Ally Mercantile, and European Cafe.

Q: Can I eat the recalled Blue Oven Bakery English Muffins if I am not allergic to milk?

Blue Oven Bakery asks all customers to return or discard the product to eliminate any chance of accidental exposure, even if they do not have a milk allergy.

Q: Have any illnesses been reported from the Blue Oven Bakery English Muffin recall?

As of November 6, 2025, no allergic reactions or illnesses have been reported.

Q: How do I contact Blue Oven Bakery about the English Muffin recall?

You can call 513-706-0901 or email blueovencustomerservice@gmail.com for assistance.

Q: Is there a lot code or UPC for the Blue Oven Bakery English Muffin recall?

No UPC was used; the recall includes all 13.04-oz English Muffins sold between 04/24/25 and 10/24/25.

Q: Can I freeze the recalled Blue Oven Bakery English Muffins until I can return them?

Freezing does not remove the allergen risk. Store the muffins in a sealed bag marked 'Do Not Eat' until returning or discarding.

Blue Oven Bakery, Inc. • November 06, 2025

Blue Oven Bakery English Muffin Recall Over Undeclared Milk Allergen

If you recently bought Blue Oven Bakery English Muffins, stop and read this recall notice. The Cincinnati-based bakery has voluntarily recalled its 13.04-oz English Muffins because they contain milk that is not listed on the ingredient label. Undeclared milk poses a potentially serious health risk to anyone with a milk allergy. Follow the refund instructions below and do not consume the product.

Action Required: Customers with a milk allergy should not eat these muffins. Return them for a full refund at 1719 Elm Street, Cincinnati, OH, on 11/4/25 or 11/5/25, or contact Blue Oven Bakery for alternate arrangements.

Blue Oven Bakery English Muffin Recall: Key Details

Product: Blue Oven Bakery English Muffin, 13.04 oz sealed plastic bag
Hazard: Undeclared milk allergen (misbranding)
Distribution window: 04/24/25 – 10/24/25
Reported illnesses: None at the time of recall
Refund location & dates: 1719 Elm St., Cincinnati, OH 45202 on 11/4/25 & 11/5/25
Consumer contact: 513-706-0901 | blueovencustomerservice@gmail.com

Sources

FDA Recall Announcement

Retail Locations That Sold Blue Oven Bakery English Muffins

The recalled muffins were distributed as fresh baked goods at the following retailers:

Harvest Market — 308 Main St., Milford, OH 45150
Country Fresh Market — 8315 Beechmont Ave. #15, Cincinnati, OH 45255
Kremers Market — 755 Buttermilk Pike, Crescent Springs, KY 41017
Back Ally Mercantile — 221 Walnut St. #102, Lawrenceburg, IN 47025
European Cafe — 9450 Montgomery Rd., Cincinnati, OH 45242

Health Risks of Undeclared Milk in Blue Oven Bakery English Muffins

Milk is one of the nine major allergens (formerly eight) that must be declared on U.S. food labels under the Food Allergen Labeling and Consumer Protection Act (FALCPA). Ingesting milk when allergic may trigger reactions that range from mild hives to life-threatening anaphylaxis.

Common Milk-Allergy Symptoms

Skin rash, hives, or itching
Swelling of lips, face, or throat
Stomach cramps, nausea, or vomiting
Wheezing or difficulty breathing
Dizziness, fainting, or anaphylaxis (call 911)

How to Get a Refund or Safely Dispose of the Recalled Muffins

For a full refund, bring the product—or proof of purchase—to Blue Oven Bakery’s stand at 1719 Elm Street, Cincinnati, OH 45202 on Tuesday, 11/4/25, or Wednesday, 11/5/25. If you cannot visit during those dates, call or email the bakery to arrange an alternative refund or replacement method. Dispose of the muffins in a way that prevents others from accidentally consuming them.

Blue Oven Bakery English Muffin Recall FAQ

Why are Blue Oven Bakery English Muffins being recalled?

The muffins contain milk that is not declared on the label, violating federal allergen-disclosure laws and putting milk-allergic consumers at risk.

Which stores carried the recalled Blue Oven Bakery English Muffins?

The product was sold at Harvest Market, Country Fresh Market, Kremers Market, Back Ally Mercantile, and European Cafe in Ohio, Kentucky, and Indiana.

Can I eat the recalled Blue Oven Bakery English Muffins if I am not allergic to milk?

While the immediate danger is to milk-allergic individuals, Blue Oven Bakery requests that all customers return or discard the product to remove any chance of accidental exposure.

Have any illnesses been reported from the Blue Oven Bakery English Muffin recall?

No allergic reactions or illnesses had been reported as of November 6, 2025.

How do I contact Blue Oven Bakery about the English Muffin recall?

Call 513-706-0901 or email blueovencustomerservice@gmail.com for assistance.

Is there a lot code or UPC for the Blue Oven Bakery English Muffin recall?

The bakery sells the muffins in clear 13.04-oz bags without a UPC. The recall covers all English Muffins sold between 04/24/25 and 10/24/25.

Can I freeze the recalled Blue Oven Bakery English Muffins until I can return them?

Freezing will not remove the allergen risk. Store the muffins in a sealed bag—preferably labeled “Do Not Eat”—until you can return or safely discard them.